Herschel Supply Co. Black Heritage Hardshell Carry-On Luggage on a white background.

Herschel Classics

Shallow Elmer Beanie
Regular price $25.00 $16.99
Sale

COLOR: BLACK

3 Options
Sale
Sale
Sale

or 4 interest-free payments of $4.25 with

  • Warm knit for cold days
  • Classic cuffed fit

Overall rating: 3.108108 / 5 from 37 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Elmer Shallow Beanie is a low-profile cold weather essential. While opinions vary on its fit, some customers find it perfect, while others feel it could be improved. Some customers criticized the hat for being oversized.

Summary topics

  • Hat Size: 20%
  • Fit: 32%

Review topics: ["fit","color","looks","beanie","quality","toque","execution"].

Review highlights

  • "Also petite woman here and it fits perfectly."A
  • "fabric and the colour of the beanie makes it look so good on the inside and outside too ."Chanpreet S.
  • "I love this model, I have many of them and they are great!"Marie-Pier T.

Reviews

What "Shallow" means really needs to be clearer

"I bought this on final sale so I can't return it which really sucks. It says that this is for an adult, but the Shallow version of the Elmer Beanie could fit on a toddler."

Mark B. (5/5)

Cute, but not quite right

"This is a hat for very small heads, which luckily I have. However, it's not the shape I was looking for. I wanted a more fisherman-style beanie and this looked like it could be right, but unfortunately it is not."

Jody M. (3/5)

Very nice

"Very nice"

Adam S. (5/5)

"love the small feel, perfect for when i just need partial ear coverage or using it to cover a bad hair day"

Dante (5/5)

Great

"Great"

Carl P. (5/5)

Elmer beanie shallow

"This thing feels like it’s meant for a toddler. Do no buy"

Vanessa G. (1/5)

My Bennie didn’t fit me

"My Bennie didn’t fit me I want it to match with my 4 month baby"

Jorge M. (1/5)

great

"great"

Arthur S. (5/5)

"Jacket is VERY oversized ans hat is very small"

Nicole (3/5)

harborside

"Poor fit, sloppy. Lazy take on a classic style, hard to do it bad. The original Elmer beanie, double cuffed, was a perfect version. All Herschel had to do was cut short one fold. You can get a better hat at the hardware store. I wrote to 'em and they ignored me. I don't buy Herschel anymore. Not the first time their quality has slipped, but this hat is a joke."

hats (1/5)

Q&A